J.P.L. Finally gone.....I consider it a miracle that JPL WAS EVEN STILL AROUND.Only reason I can see why is the chicks seen something in him - sorry, but he can't sing. I felt like he was singing in a kareoke bar every week. Great guy and a lot of fun, but needs major singing lessons...well now its time for John S to go...

If someone would hone that kids voice (JPL's), I can imagine he'd do well on a broadway stage. He has the projection and can hit the notes if he'd just learn how to breathe. And for crying out loud...make him stop that ridiculous dancing! LOL!

This is the time in the show when ya know someone has to go, but they are all so good in their own right that it's sad when they get the boot!

every time I hear John Stevens sing, I think: High school play. He'd do well on broadway, I think.

I'm sorry PL had to go, but they're down to the talen now, and each week will be hard to see someone go.

I agree, Gilly. They're down to the cream of the crop now. I hate to see any of them go, with one notable exception. But that has nothing to do with talent.

Are there any guesses who will be the next to go?? Not who you WANT to go, but who you THINK will go. :D

As much as I like Diana, she's been on the bottom for a bit now, so I don't know how well she'll do next week. Jennifer Hdson I am torn on. She has given some steller performances, and she has given some bottom of the barrel performances.

I don't know how much longer John has in him, because his voice is so type specific. Once they throw him a genre he can't do, I don't thik he'll make it.

I agree on John, but I think he'll make it through this week. They'll be doing Barry Manilow music and Barry himself is doing the arrangements for the contestants. This should be right up John's alley. I think LaToya should do well too. I don't think there's anything she can't sing. She's not my favorite, but I will say she seems to be able to sing any genre. I'm not as sure about Fantasia, George or Jennifer. It's really going to all come to which song they choose for themselves. I also agree Diana is a bit weak and this could be her week to go.

Has anyone been watching Nashville Star?

I have to add my agreement that this is probably Diana's week to go. With all that's said about John Stevens, I think this will be his week to shine. With regards to Diana though, I'm really shocked that she didn't go last week, because I thought that her out-of-tune, inconsistent performance last week was worse than what JPL's lacked in musicality.

Thank you R4T! As cute as she is I have to agree with you!! I just feel l ike, of all the celine dion songs you could sing (if you can pull it off) that song, although a good one, is sooo played out and boring. I also think that after all the bad dancing (which can be cute sometimes) it finally fit when JPL was singing jailhouse rock. I just think everything is up in the air right now, but if I had to pick I would say it's Diana next. I love her and think she is cute and has a pretty good voice, but I I just think it's her time to go. ok and now I will stop repeating myself...lol

Diana just sang (first singer) and I really thought she nailed it. Yay!

Really? I thought quite the opposite, as did my friend that I'm watching it. She really was off-pitch throughout the whole song. But we appear to be in the minority with that thinking, because the judges seemed to like it. Who knows. I just don't think that she matches up to everyone else tonight.
I also thought that Jennifer did fantastic tonight. It was good to see her come into her own.

I think George was rotten, and John wasn't great, either.

I'd love to see Fantasia gone, because of her Diva tendancies. Not a big Jennier fan, either.

It's very sad but I think George was the worst tonight. Is it me or is Jennifer super scary when she sings. She just makes strange faces.

45 more minutes and it will be on here. I can't wait!

I liked John tonight... but mainly because he sang my song. :) I was hoping that he would. He started out really strong, but the end was kinda weak. I agree that George wasn't fantastic. He was good, but not as good as usual. Camille was alright. LaToya I thought did fairly well. No one really shined except Jennifer I thought. I missed the last performance tonight, was that Fantasia? I'm not sure. But that's my $.02.

Camille? Jasmine. ;)

Yes, Fantasia was the last performance, and her ego is as big as ever. I'm thinking it'll definatly be George to go this week. Though, John doesn't have many supporter's around. If you look at the Idol forum (the official one), most people want him gone.

It makes me think he's on borrowed time, whether he puts in a good performance or not.

Did they say what they'll be doing next week? I didn't hear.